https://x.com/enginesofroblox/status/1924773120222618058

EOR🚂 (@enginesofroblox) on XX (formerly Twitter)

Alternatively for those that doesn't use Twitter: https://xcancel.com/enginesofroblox/status/1924773120222618058

@Jammer077 Your son did such an amazing job with singing this!

As I am leaving soon, I would like for you to help my friend Thomasfan48573 with his wiki. His goal is 120 pages, but with your help, we can make it bigger. Please help on this wiki as much as possible. Thank you. https://theunofficialthomtoys.fandom.com/wiki/TheUnofficialThomtoys_Wiki

TheUnofficialThomtoys Wiki@getfandom

I decided to do this again, as the last time I did this was in 2022, so no Henry, Ashima, Salty, anyone released after that back then, and my opinions have changed on some of the models. But before I start:

1. No Variants included in this list.

2. No characters who are exclusive to packs/sets.

3. None of the plastic PA's are included.

Link to the OG Ranking I did 3 years ago:

https://thomas-and-friends-all-engines-go.fandom.com/f/p/4400000000000150055/r/4400000000000438047

So, let's start:

Top tier/Good Tier:

-Kana: 10/10, literally perfect and accurate in any way

-Percy: 10/10, Nice details, and accurate to the show

-Thomas: 10/10, Nice details

-Whiff: 9/10, Ok He has nice details and FINALLY painted wheels for once, all wheels are detailed on him. One nitpick is that he’s quite smaller than someone like Thomas and Percy

-Salty: 9/10, Same reason as Whiff, but another nitpick is that Salty’s back buffers aren’t painted.

-Carly: 9/10, Not a fan of how her crane arm snaps a lot.

-Sandy: 9/10, she’s almost perfect, but the shovel took one point away for this being perfect.

-Duck: 8/10, still dislike the yellow wheels, but again, it’s just me that’s not liking that specific design on him. Do like the reflective-ish handrails, and quite detailed. I do think this model is waaay better than his final model in the show (Minus the yellow wheels and irises, those are the only things I’m glad they changed in the final render.)

-Toby: 8/10, Massive step up from the atrocious looking PA Model from the og line. Despite this, I really dislike how they painted the wood lining on his sides, but not for his front and back ones.

-Troublesome Truck: 8/10, really like his face, but he’s too wide compare to the others.

-Bruno: 8/10, wheels aren’t painted.

-Kenji: 8/10, love the coach he comes with, but it's too short. No wheel detailing, but not much of an issue here with Kenji, unlike most of them....

-Diesel: 8/10, not a fan of the purple tint, but that's just me not liking the design.

-Winston: 8/10. Ok, Winston is probably the only one who is sort of unfair, since I don't actually have his model, but I feel bad to not rank him, despite not owning him (Bro was never released in my country). I will say, after seeing reviews of him online, he looks quite good, yeah no painted wheels, but I don't see it much as an issue on Winston. He looks small, and I'm fine, he is supposed to be small, yet Take-N-Play and Adventures made him big, like what? he's supposed to be small.

Mid-tier:

-James: 7/10, Again, no wheel detailing (Though on James, it isn't as bad), but his buffers are painted so that’s a bonus I suppose. (yes, I will definitely repeat “Missing wheel detailing”)

-Emily: 7/10, Ok you gave detailing to her driving wheel, but why did they leave the other wheels un-detailed. Also, tender is too short, it’s too small.

-Ashima: 7/10, So many missing details, this is basically Nia but the other way around, where the proportions and such are good, but then there’s lack of detailing.

-Harold: 7/10, let’s be honest, I am not a fan of Harold’s AEG design, but again, that’s just me. However, It does capture Harold's AEG Model great, and I like how they use white instead of cream.

-Gordon: 6/10, Buffers are not painted, missing wheel detailing, but decent looking, his proportions don't look that bad.

-Yong Bao: 6/10, Unpainted wheels, but at least he has more details and looks proportionally decent, unlike some other engine we’ll tackle later….

Bad tier:

-Nia: 5/10, Nice details, bad proportions

-Henry: 5/10, Ok I’m glad they didn’t straight up paint Gordon green and call it a day, I like how they changed the firebox, window, add the top feed, and face is modified a bit. But still, his back running board dips diagonally, instead of Vertical, and his nose shape is just reused from Gordon.

-Edward: 5/10, I mean, he’s not accurate to his AEG render, but I think it’s better? Still got the issue of the leading wheels not properly touching the tracks.

And finally, In my opinion, the worst AEG PA Model goes to.....

Hiro: 4/10, Theres sooo many things wrong here, His cab is too short, he seems to be missing a lot of details, unpainted wheels.

So, that'd be it for this ranking. Hope you guys enjoyed reading this whole rambling about the PA engines.

Ranking on The Push Along AEG Engines | FandomThe Main Cast: Thomas = 10/10, So accurate, and…thomas-and-friends-all-engines-go.fandom.com